If you just bought a home in New Braunfels, yes: rekey every exterior lock. You cannot know how many keys exist for a resale house, and a rekey makes every old key stop working. A residential rekey is $30 per lock with a 3-lock minimum, so three locks come to $90 before the keyset, parts and tax. Call WOW Locks at (844) 969-5625.
The rest of this page covers who may still hold a key, which doors go first, what changes between older and newer homes, and what it costs. A key you never counted still turns the lock.
Counting the Keys: What the Seller Handed You Versus What Is Still Out There
You usually get the keys the seller chose to hand over, and no way to know about the rest. Past owners, family, a former renter and a contractor may each have kept a copy. Nobody can give you a number. Rekeying cuts the question off, because the lock stops accepting every key cut for the old pins.
| Who may hold access | How it usually happens | What closes it |
|---|---|---|
| Previous owners and family | A spare was kept or never returned | Rekey the exterior locks |
| Former renter or house-sitter | If the house was ever rented or watched | Rekey the exterior locks |
| Repair or remodel crews | A copy may be cut for the job | Rekey the exterior locks |
| Hidden spares | A key under a planter or a lockbox left on site | Find it, then rekey |
| Garage and keypad codes | Codes count as keys | Reset every code |
Schlage describes the result on its Advanced Rekey product page: once a lock is rekeyed, the old key no longer works. That is the whole point of the job. Our rekey service page covers how the work goes, and our New Braunfels locksmith page lists the ZIP codes we cover.
Do Real Estate Agents and Lockboxes Leave Keys Behind?
A listing runs on shared access. Agents, showing partners and the lockbox itself can all open the door, and a lockbox or code that nobody removed is still a way in. We cannot tell you how often a copy lingers. We can tell you a rekey plus a code reset leaves the house with one set of keys, yours.

A Texas county sheriff’s office puts it plainly on its home security tips page:
“Re-key the locks any time you buy a home, lose a key, or have a contractor with key access leave the job.”
That is a county in the Austin and San Marcos area, not Comal County, but the advice holds for any resale house. If you see a lockbox still hanging on the door or a gate, ask the listing agent to remove it. Then reset the code on any electronic lock or alarm panel. A code is a key you cannot see.
Past Renters, Repair Crews and Old Codes: Access Nobody Told You About
Ask the seller two things: was the house ever rented, and who worked on it. A past renter or a weekend guest may still have a key, and a repair crew may have cut a copy for the job. If the answer is “I do not know,” treat it as yes. Garage keypads and smart-lock codes need a reset too.
Three things to pin down before closing day wraps up:
- Rental history: was anyone ever a tenant, a house-sitter or a regular guest?
- Crews and cleaners: who had access for repairs, painting or cleaning?
- Codes: list every keypad, garage code and alarm code, and reset each one.
Movers and cleaners who may hold copies are covered in our PCS rekey checklist for San Antonio homes. If the house was a weekend or short-term rental, our guide for lake house rental hosts explains why codes alone are not enough. And if you bought the place to rent it out, read about rekeying between tenants.
Older Gruene-Area Homes Versus Newer Neighborhoods: What Changes
Homes near the Gruene Historic District can be older, so you may find original or mismatched hardware, and a latch that sticks is a repair question before a rekey one. Homes in newer master-planned areas such as Veramendi and Mayfair are more likely to need only a straight rekey. Both are rules of thumb, not facts about any one house. We look at each door.

Older homes. An older house often has a mix of hardware from different decades on one set of doors. Some of it rekeys fine. A worn knob that sticks, a plate that has loosened or a lock that does not match its door may be better replaced than rekeyed. If you are not sure how your lock works, our post on how a deadbolt works is a short read.
Newer homes. In newer neighborhoods the locks are usually in better shape, and the job tends to be a straight rekey so every door takes one key. For the same situation on a brand-new house, see our new-build rekey guide.
Rekey, Replace or Upgrade: What to Do With Each Door
Rekey when the lock works and the only issue is the unknown keys. Replace when it sticks, spins loose, is badly worn or does not match the door. Upgrade to a smart lock when you want codes instead of keys. A rekey keeps your hardware and changes which key works. Smart lock installs are a custom quote after we see the door.
| Door condition | Usual choice | What to watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Works smoothly, brand matches | Rekey | Nothing more to do |
| Sticks or needs a jiggle | Repair or replace, we look first | A fix that keeps coming back points to wear |
| Loose, rusted or worn through | Replace with a new deadbolt, $90 | Hardware is extra if we supply it |
| Mixed brands on one house | Rekey and key alike where the parts are compatible, else replace | Some cylinders cannot match each other |
| You want codes, not keys | Smart lock, custom quote | No figure until we see the door |
For the full matrix on a different city, our guide on rekey versus replace walks through five questions. Our deadbolt installation page covers replacements, and smart lock installation covers the upgrade path.
Which Doors to Rekey on Day One, in Order
Start with the doors people actually use, then the ones they forget. Front door, back or patio door and the garage entry come first, then side doors, then any gate or outbuilding with its own lock. Getting everything onto one key is the point, so ask for matching keys when you call.
- The front door.
- The back or patio door.
- The garage entry door.
- Side doors and gates, plus any shed or outbuilding with its own lock.
- Keypads and codes: garage, alarm and smart locks.
Count test: Walk the outside of the house before you call. Count every keyed lock, door by door, and write the number down. A knob and a deadbolt on one door are two locks.
That number drives the quote. Give it to the dispatcher, and you hear the price, add-ons included, before anyone is dispatched.
What a Resale Rekey Costs (Rate Card: $30 per Lock, 3-Lock Minimum)
A residential rekey is $30 per lock with a 3-lock minimum, and a new set of two keys adds $15. Parts and tax are additional. Extra keys, after-hours calls and distance are quoted on the call before a technician is dispatched. Smart lock installs are a custom quote after we see the door.
| Item | Published rate | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Residential rekey | $30 per lock | 3-lock minimum |
| New keyset (2 keys) | +$15 | Parts and tax additional |
| New deadbolt or doorknob | $90 | Hardware additional if we supply it |
| Extra keys, after-hours, distance | Quoted on the call | Before anyone is dispatched |
| Smart lock installation | Custom quote | After we see the door |
Plain arithmetic: 3 locks x $30 = $90 before keysets, parts and tax. Four locks come to $120. Our published rate card shows what is posted and what is quoted.
What to Tell the Dispatcher Before the Visit
Tell the dispatcher how many exterior locks you have, the door types, any hardware that sticks or does not match, and whether you want everything on one key. The quote comes before anyone is dispatched. Local San Antonio-area technicians handle New Braunfels, which sits about 32 miles northeast of downtown San Antonio.
- Count your locks, door by door.
- Note any hardware that sticks or does not match.
- Say you want matching keys.
- Hear the quote and confirm.
Call (844) 969-5625 or use the request service form. Our page for rekey service in New Braunfels has the local details. Readers on the Hill Country edge can see our Helotes page, and the wider area is on the San Antonio metro page.
WOW Locks was founded in 2021, and our technicians have 17+ years of locksmith experience. WOW Locks LLC is insured and bonded and holds Texas DPS (TOPS) license B10595301. Texas licenses locksmith companies under Texas Occupations Code Chapter 1702, and you can check any company’s license on the state’s TOPS portal before you book. Get the keys counted, and the question closed.